The Minor’s Evaluation Report as a Mechanism of Legal Protection

Abstract

In contemporary legal systems, the legal regime applicable to juvenile offenders represents a central point of interest within criminal law policies, particularly due to the complexity arising from the psychosocial characteristics of minors. The present study analyzes the normative architecture of the juvenile delinquency regime in Romanian criminal legislation, highlighting the importance of the evaluation report prepared by probation services. This document proves to be an essential tool for individualizing educational measures and applying proportional sanctions, fully aligned with the personal characteristics of the minor. Furthermore, the paper discusses relevant legislative amendments that have contributed to refining the sanctioning system for minors, emphasizing the role of evaluation in ensuring procedural fairness and supporting the social reintegration of minors in conflict with criminal law. The study also examines the legal implications arising from the absence of such an evaluation report during criminal proceedings, as well as the criteria for its validation in relation to judicial procedural requirements. Finally, attention is drawn to the necessity of clarifying the limits of applying the exception concerning the best interests of the child, as well as establishing a standardized framework for drafting and evaluating reports, aimed at strengthening the legal protection afforded to minors.